Make Motherhood Diverse

Motherhood stories

Why representation matters in parenting media

What the evidence shows about who gets left out of parenting advice, why it can affect care, and how to judge what you read.

Three women from different generations of a family laugh together, arms around each other.

Watching for yellow skin sounds like clear advice for the parents of a newborn. For a family whose baby has black or brown skin, it is much less use. The NHS page on jaundice in babies now says it “can be harder to see yellow on black or brown skin”, and shows parents where else to look, such as the whites of the eyes.

That single sentence shows what is at stake when people talk about representation in parenting media. The subject is often treated as a question of whose face appears in the photograph. Sometimes it is. But it can also decide whether a piece of information works for the person reading it.

When the imagined reader is too narrow, advice can stop working

The jaundice example has a wider history. A 2023 review by the NHS Race and Health Observatory examined three standard newborn checks: the Apgar score and the assessment of cyanosis and jaundice. It found they had been developed based on White European babies and normalised regardless of how well they applied to babies with other skin tones. Because these checks focus on skin colour, the review warned, they have the potential to disadvantage babies with darker skin. A parent reading a guide that repeats “pink” and “blue” without explanation inherits the same blind spot.

Tone and framing matter as well as facts. In research for the UK government published in 2025, based on 46 ethnic minority women and 25 maternity staff in four cities, NHS information often felt less relatable or applicable to the women involved. One staff member in Bristol said material can read as if “the audience is middle-class mothers”. Some women turned instead to friends, family, community organisations and social media, which some found empowering and others found frightening. This was exploratory research and cannot be generalised to all women, but it shows how a reader who does not see themselves in official advice may simply go elsewhere.

The stakes in maternity care are high. MBRRACE-UK data for 2022 to 2024 show that the maternal mortality rate for women from Black ethnic backgrounds in England was nearly three times that of White women. Nothing in those figures shows that media coverage causes this gap, and it would be wrong to suggest it. The causes are examined in our article on Black maternal health in the UK. The figures do explain why women in those communities need information that takes their risks and experiences seriously.

What research can and cannot tell us about seeing yourself

The phrase “representation matters” is often repeated as settled science. The picture is more mixed, and a publication that asks readers to judge evidence should be plain about that.

One frequently discussed study followed 396 Black and White preadolescent children in the US over time. After controlling for age, body satisfaction and starting self-esteem, greater television exposure predicted a fall in self-esteem for White girls, Black girls and Black boys, and a rise for White boys. The authors interpreted this through theories about how media shapes people’s sense of their social group. It is a striking result, but the study measured exposure to television, so it cannot show which portrayals made the difference, and it comes from one country and one period of television.

There is related evidence from family life. A meta-analysis of 102 studies found that parents teaching children of colour about their ethnic and racial background was positively, though modestly, associated with how children see themselves and with the quality of their relationships. That concerns parents, not media, but it supports the broader idea that positive messages about who you are can matter.

A fair summary is that the evidence makes it reasonable to care about representation, while falling short of proving that any particular image or storyline will raise a child’s self-esteem. The strongest case rests on something simpler: information built around one kind of family can be inaccurate or irrelevant for others.

Who tends to be missing

No single dataset measures representation across UK parenting media, so it would be misleading to offer one figure. Several sources do show where the gaps are likely to lie.

Children from racially minoritised backgrounds. The annual Reflecting Realities survey from the Centre for Literacy in Primary Education tracks UK children’s books. It found that 24% of books published in 2024 featured a racially minoritised character, up from 17% in 2023 but still below the 30% reported in 2022. Main characters from these backgrounds swung from 7% to 24% in a single year. Representation is clearly not a steady march forward, and it can fall as easily as it rises.

Most of the world’s children, in the research behind the advice. Parenting tips frequently draw on child development studies. When researchers reviewed three leading developmental psychology journals from 2006 to 2010, just over 90% of participant samples came from Western, educated, industrialised, rich and democratic backgrounds, and nearly 58% from the United States alone. African samples made up 0.63%. So when an article says “research shows children need X”, it is worth asking which children were studied.

Fathers as carers. A University of Nebraska study of 50 articles from five popular American parenting magazines found most perpetuated the idea that fathers are too masculine to be nurturing. It is a small US study, but it is a useful reminder that narrow portrayals affect many kinds of parents.

Disabled parents and single parents. Gingerbread’s figures show that a third of single parents in the UK are disabled, a fact seldom reflected in the usual image of family life. On screen, the Creative Diversity Network’s analysis of UK television concluded that disabled people had been excluded from the industry’s diversity conversation. Our article on single parenting without the stereotypes looks at how far popular assumptions depart from the data.

Families whose main language is not English. The 2021 Census found that 91.1% of residents of England and Wales aged three and over had English or Welsh as a main language, leaving almost one in eleven who did not, although most of that group were proficient in English. The Care Quality Commission’s national review of maternity services found some trusts where people experienced discrimination linked to their ethnic background or to English not being their preferred language. A guide written only in dense, idiomatic English can shut out parents who most need clear information.

Good representation goes beyond a diverse stock photo

It is easy to add a varied image to an unchanged article. Readers can look for signs of something more substantial. Does the advice change where it needs to, for different skin tones, family structures, disabilities, faiths, languages or incomes? Are people from a community writing, advising or being quoted about their own lives, or only being described? Does a piece about, say, co-sleeping or discipline acknowledge that norms vary between cultures, while being clear about what safety guidance says? Are difficulties attributed to a group’s culture when poverty, racism or poor services may be a better explanation?

Inclusion also has limits. A warm and affirming post can still be wrong. A resource that makes you feel seen deserves the same scrutiny as one that does not.

How to judge what you read

You do not need specialist training to assess parenting content. Six questions cover most of it, and our guide to finding trustworthy parenting information goes further.

  1. Who is this written for? Picture your own child and family. Would the signs, examples and suggestions work for them? If a health article describes a rash or colour change, does it say how that looks on darker skin?
  2. Who made it, and who paid? The UK’s advertising regulator expects influencer ads to carry a prominent “ad” label upfront, and notes that its research found people really struggle to identify when posts are ads. If someone is recommending a product, check for that label, and treat a missing one with suspicion.
  3. What is the evidence, and who was in it? Look for a link to the original source. A study of a few dozen families in one US city does not automatically apply to yours.
  4. Which country does it apply to? Law, benefits, vaccination schedules and services differ, including between England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland.
  5. Has anyone checked the process? In the UK, the PIF TICK is an independently assessed certification for health information. Its criteria include using reliable evidence, involving users and addressing health inequalities such as language and accessibility needs. Its absence does not make a source bad, but its presence tells you something.
  6. Who is missing from this? Ask whose experience would change the advice if it were included. Sometimes the answer is that the article is fine for its audience, and you need a second source for your situation.

Try this week: audit five sources

Take the five parenting accounts, websites or apps you use most. For each, write down who appears, who is giving the advice, and whether any of it is paid for. If they all show the same kind of family, keep the ones you value and add one source that reflects a part of your life they leave out, such as a charity for your child’s condition or a community organisation.

Then take the habit into your next appointment. When a midwife, health visitor or GP describes a symptom, ask: “What would that look like on my baby’s skin?” If you think a baby may have jaundice, the NHS advises an urgent GP or midwife appointment or a call to NHS 111 for a baby over 24 hours old. Call 999 or go to A&E if a baby with jaundice is under 24 hours old, unusually sleepy or hard to wake, not feeding, floppy or stiff, or has trouble breathing.

Sources

  1. Jaundice in babies, NHS. Accessed 21 November 2026.
  2. Review of neonatal assessment and practice in Black, Asian, and minority ethnic newborns: Executive Summary, NHS Race and Health Observatory. Accessed 21 November 2026.
  3. Confidence in maternity care services: engagement with ethnic minority women and maternity staff, Office for Equality and Opportunity, GOV.UK. Accessed 21 November 2026.
  4. Maternal death rates in the UK 20% higher in 2022-24 than 2009-11, MBRRACE-UK, National Perinatal Epidemiology Unit. Accessed 21 November 2026.
  5. Racial and Gender Differences in the Relationship Between Children's Television Use and Self-Esteem: A Longitudinal Panel Study, Communication Research. Accessed 21 November 2026.
  6. Parental ethnic-racial socialization practices and children of color's psychosocial and behavioral adjustment: A systematic review and meta-analysis, American Psychologist. Accessed 21 November 2026.
  7. Reflecting Realities: Survey of Ethnic Representation within UK Children's Literature, School Library Association, reporting CLPE. Accessed 21 November 2026.
  8. The persistent sampling bias in developmental psychology: A call to action, Journal of Experimental Child Psychology. Accessed 21 November 2026.
  9. Study: Parenting magazines still reinforce traditional gender roles, University of Nebraska–Lincoln. Accessed 21 November 2026.
  10. Single parents facts and figures, Gingerbread. Accessed 21 November 2026.
  11. Disability Representation in UK TV, Creative Diversity Network. Accessed 21 November 2026.
  12. Language, England and Wales: Census 2021, Office for National Statistics. Accessed 21 November 2026.
  13. Inequalities and racism, Care Quality Commission. Accessed 21 November 2026.
  14. Recognising ads: Social media and influencer marketing, Advertising Standards Authority and Committee of Advertising Practice. Accessed 21 November 2026.
  15. Getting PIF TICK Certification, Patient Information Forum. Accessed 21 November 2026.

This article is general information. It has not been reviewed by a clinician or lawyer and does not replace advice about your own situation.